This Make-Ahead Mashed Potato Casserole is a holiday miracle. Cooked in herbed half-and-half and topped with fried sage, you’ll swoon over the crispy-yet-creamy texture as much as all of the avoided last-minute stress.
MAKE-AHEAD MASHED POTATO CASSEROLE
I spend 150% of the holiday season stressed out because time management is not the strong suit of the over-ambitious and perfectionists. That’s especially true when it comes to Thanksgiving, because who can really be sure that their turkey will be finished at the same time as the mashed potatoes, stuffing, rolls and green beans? NOT I. Not usually.
Naturally, a reliable make-ahead recipe is an absolute godsend (because when you don’t have to scramble around at the last second, hosting sure goes a whole lot smoother), but unfortunately, most traditional Thanksgiving foods tend to wither and die when you cook them ahead of time.
Stuffing? Soggy. Turkey? Don’t even think about it. Mashed potatoes? Thanks but no thanks. OR SO YOU THOUGHT.
So I thought too, until I discovered a few recipes for “Duchess Mashed Potato Casserole” around the web. A modern and more practical take on “Pomme Duchesse” (you know, those fancy little piped mashed potato bites), turning make-ahead mashed potatoes into casserole means they reheat like an absolute dream. With a few small tweaks, I was able to come up with a recipe I actually prefer over the regular “real thing”. That’s right, I said it: I like this Make-Ahead Mashed Potato Casserole MORE than regular mashed potatoes. By a landslide, actually.
Flavorful and creamy with a crisp, browned crust, the dish is as satisfying on its own as it is topped with your favorite gravy.
The secret? There are a few actually, but luckily for you I’ve never been great at keeping secrets.
IT ALL STARTS WITH THE PERFECT MASHED POTATO BASE
Mashed potatoes are not like salad; you don’t just toss it all together and mix. The base you choose and the way you combine your ingredients make all the difference when it comes to nailing that blissfully smooth texture. Here’s how to pull it off:
- Start with yukon gold potatoes. Just like russets are great for baking and red potatoes hold up well in soups, Yukon Golds are a perfect pick for your mash. They’re starchy enough that they don’t get gluey, but creamy enough that you’ll wind up with a velvety, glossy bowl of goodness to pass around.
- Skip the water, pass the cream. Boiling potatoes in water? Sure, if this was Thanksgiving of 1621. Fortunately we’ve learned a thing or two since then, in this case, from Chef Jamie Oliver. Inspired by his (wildly underrated) Thanksgiving hack, we’ll add extra flavor by boiling our potatoes in half-and-half seasoned with bay leaves, thyme, and garlic.
- Rice your potatoes. Even if you don’t have a “legit” ricer, you can get the job done by pushing your potatoes through the holes of a cheese grater. (However, a good ricer really does make everything easier!) The point here is to avoid lumps while evenly coat your spuds in butter. This, my friends, is the secret to keeping mashed potatoes from turning gluey as you mix in the half-and-half.
- Waste Not, Want Not. Remember that boiling liquid I told you not to throw away? Get ready for a very happy reunion. Since no mashed potato is complete without a little something creamy, it’s the perfect way to make use of that deeply flavored half-and-half.
EGG YOLKS MAKE FOR RICHER, TASTIER, REHEATABLE MASHED POTATOES
For a rich and tasty mashed potato, most of us turn to dairy. Cream, butter, and maybe even some shredded cheese. But would you believe me if I told you that eggs are the secret to this tasty and freezer-friendly dish?
Because of their relatively low water-to-fat content, egg yolks add richness without watering down your potatoes.
They’re also emulsifiers (#science) which seem to keep the liquid ingredients from separating as you cool, refrigerate, and reheat the dish. Not sold on it yet? Well, as they say, “the proof is in the pudding”, or in this case, the potatoes.
THE GOLDEN BROWN TOP IS (MAYBE) THE BEST PART
You know how people go crazy for creme brulee? It’s not the sugar. In my opinion, it’s the satisfaction of cracking into a crispy, caramelized top and scooping up a spoonful of custardy goodness. That heavenly texture pairing is a multi-sensory experience, and basically culinary Nirvana.
It really doesn’t get much better – until you add butter and garlic.
…Not into the creme brulee. Into something with a crust like a creme brulee. Uh, rewind a second.
What I’m trying to say is that if you love crispy-meets-creamy, Make-Ahead Mashed Potato Casserole is as good as it gets. Because while the egg yolks add richness to the interior, the egg whites (plus butter) encourage the top to brown and crisp for ultimate savory satisfaction.
HOW LONG IN ADVANCE CAN I MAKE THE MASHED POTATO CASSEROLE?
There are three ways to store this dish depending on how much time you need. Mashed Potato Casserole is best enjoyed after its first bake; so if you’ve got oven the space but not the time, prepare the casserole as instructed and stop once you smooth the potatoes into the baking dish.
If you’re making this recipe 1-2 days before Thanksgiving, go ahead and pop it in the fridge before you finish it off in the oven. Need more time? It will keep in the freezer up to 2 weeks.
If your oven is truly overbooked though, go ahead and fully cook your casserole. If I’m being honest, I’ve reheated these leftovers 5 days later and it was (almost) as good as the original.
MASHED POTATO CASSEROLE MIX-INS
Ready to go rogue?
While the half-and-half is seasoned in recipe, adding some background notes to the mashed potatoes, the flavors of the garlic and herbs don’t come through very intensely (as to not overpower the dishes on your holiday table). However, if you want to kick it up a bit, you can easily add in some mix-ins for an extra boost.
Some of my favorite mix-ins include extra minced garlic, chives, cheddar, and goat cheese. However, you could easily get ultra-creative with it. Almost anything that normally pairs well with potatoes will do fine mixed up into this Make-Ahead Mashed Potato Casserole!
WATCH THE MAKE AHEAD MASHED POTATO CASSEROLE VIDEO
MORE RECIPES YOU CAN MAKE AHEAD FOR THE HOLIDAYS
- Make-Ahead Rosemary Sweet Potato Rolls
- The Best Cornbread Stuffing with Sausage and Bacon
- Bacon Jalapeño Popper Creamed Corn Gratin
- Pesto Parmesan Spinach Balls
- Pumpkin Spice Latte Tiramisu
- 5 pounds (about 12 medium-sized) Yukon gold potatoes, peeled and quartered
- 5 cups half-and-half
- 8 cloves garlic, peeled and gently smashed
- 4 sprigs fresh thyme
- 2 bay leaves
- 10 tablespoons butter, divided
- Kosher salt and black pepper
- 5 large egg yolks and 1 egg white, divided
- 1 bunch fresh sage leaves
- Coarse salt, to top
- Preheat oven to 450°F. Butter a large baking dish and set aside.
- Add the potatoes to a large pot or dutch oven and cover with the half-and-half. Add garlic, thyme, and bay leaves and season with salt.
- Bring to a gentle boil, reduce to a simmer, and continue to cook until a fork can pierce the potatoes with no resistance, about 20 minutes.
- Strain the potatoes, reserving the half-and-half for later. Discard the thyme and bay leaves. Return the pot to low heat and melt 8 tablespoons of butter in it.
- When the butter has melted, rice the potatoes into the pot. Stir well until the potatoes are broken down and the butter is incorporated.
- Mix in 1 1/2 cups of the reserved half-and-half and 5 egg yolks. Season generously with salt and pepper.
- Transfer the potato mixture to the buttered baking dish and smooth with a spatula into an even layer. In a small bowl, microwave the 2 remaining tablespoons of butter (covered), to melt, allow to cool slightly, and mix in 1 egg white. Pour the butter and egg mixture over the potatoes and tilt the baking dish as necessary to cover the potatoes.
- Using the back of a spoon, make indentations or waves in the potatoes. Transfer to the oven and bake until well-browned, about 30 minutes.
- Meanwhile, heat a small layer of oil in a skillet over medium-high heat. Fry the sage leaves, one at a time, until crisp, about 15 seconds. Sprinkle with coarse salt.
- Top the mashed potato casserole with the crispy sage and serve warm.